Pierre Huyghe often describes exhibitions as beginnings. Most artists complete work before opening day; Huyghe’s works continue to change throughout the exhibition period, incorporating viewers, time, and contingency into their structure. In interviews, he has described his interest in placing visitors inside an exhibition as a living system, to observe what happens when people are thrown into conditions they cannot immediately read.

This was why, when Liminal opened at Punta della Dogana in Venice in 2024, I traveled to see it. And why, when the exhibition traveled to Leeum Museum of Art in Seoul in 2025, I traveled again. I wanted to see what translation does to a work designed around disorientation.

Venice: Being Thrown

The first room at Punta della Dogana is darkened. On a large screen, a naked woman performs gestures. Her face, through to the back of her head, is hollow. It is simply absent: when she turns sideways, the background shows through where her face should be. Concrete blocks are placed across the floor in the near-darkness. Several visitors stumbled. A guard called out: no flash. Someone had turned on their phone light to navigate.

This is the exhibition functioning exactly as designed. Huyghe places visitors in conditions they cannot read, and watches what occurs. The stumbling and the guard’s warning are both part of the system.

Behind Liminal, Human Mask plays on a large screen in a loop. A monkey wearing a human mask and dress moves through an empty izakaya in Fukushima’s exclusion zone, performing service gestures (bringing hand towels to tables, carrying sake bottles) in a space uninhabited since 2011.

Watching this alongside Western visitors wearing audio guides, I became aware of a gap. For a Japanese viewer, the izakaya carries its own meaning: it is where colleagues gather after work, and where social hierarchies loosen for a while. Saru mawashi, traditional monkey performance, carries its own complex history of labor and spectacle. Fukushima remains an open wound in Japanese collective memory. Huyghe builds this gap into the work, and cultural translation becomes a condition the viewer lives through.

Liminal shows a faceless human body. Human Mask shows a monkey wearing a human face. In both, identity is prosthetic: it can be removed and handed over. What constitutes a self when the face can be absent, or borrowed?

This question runs through UUmwelt-Annlee. In 1999, Huyghe and Philippe Parreno purchased AnnLee, a minor manga character from a Japanese animation company, intended for disposal, and distributed this empty figure to artists, each of whom filled her form with content. The project’s title, No Ghost Just a Shell, drew directly from Masamune Shirow’s Ghost in the Shell, a cyberpunk manga about consciousness and the boundary between human and artificial intelligence. Huyghe found a figure for his central concerns (identity as a vessel, the self as a construction) in the margins of the Japanese anime economy. That makes sense: in Japanese visual culture, the bishōjo has long served as an empty form awaiting projection. Western artists discovered in it a structure they needed.

UUmwelt extends this further: through neuroscience research from Kyoto University’s Kamitani Laboratory, brain activity recorded during visual experience and during dreams is fed into machine learning systems, generating imagery from cognitive states that cannot otherwise be externalized. The work asks whether shared consciousness without language is possible. It also asks whether the attempt itself reveals an arrogance: the assumption that we can access another’s perceptual world at all.

Seoul: What Translation Adds and Removes

Several months later at Leeum Museum of Art, the same works were not the same works.

The concrete blocks in the first room were positioned in a well-lit area. There was no possibility of stumbling. A figure in a mask, speaking Idiom, a language generated by AI, was accompanied by a museum staff member who lit the floor ahead with a flashlight, guiding visitors safely around it.

Both decisions are defensible. Both change the work.

In Venice, visitors were thrown. In Seoul, visitors were guided. The disorientation Huyghe designs into the experience (the darkness, the stumbling, not knowing what is work and what is staff) had been partly resolved in the name of visitor safety and operations. The work gained accessibility. It lost the condition of not knowing where you are.

Liminal’s faceless figure, which I had read as motion capture in Venice, revealed itself in Seoul as AI-generated. The movements were more overtly artificial, the generative process more visible. In Seoul, Liminal and Human Mask were installed back-to-back, creating a direct dialogue the Venice spatial arrangement had not produced. With the faceless human and the human-faced monkey facing each other across a threshold, the reversal was now built into the space itself.

Camata, in which robotic arms rearrange glass spheres around skeletal remains in a desert, had evolved its machine learning algorithms between the two showings. A work dated “on-going” had, in fact, continued.

Huyghe’s claim that exhibitions are beginnings describes a material fact about how these works exist in time. What I saw in Venice was one version; what I saw in Seoul was another. The translation between them (geographic, institutional and cultural) brought both gain and loss. For Huyghe, that gap may be the work itself.